AI Policy

Policy Overview

Journal

Journal of Islamic Law and Legal Studies (JILLS)

Publisher

Yayasan Mabadi Iqtishad Al Islami

Policy Scope

Authors, Reviewers, and Editors

AI-Assisted Writing

Limited to language and readability improvement

AI Disclosure

Required in the Author Ethics Statement

AI Authorship

Not Permitted

AI-Generated Images

Prohibited, subject to documented research-method exceptions

Peer Review Confidentiality

Strictly Protected

AI-Based Editorial Decisions

Not Permitted

Editorial Authority

Editor-in-Chief and Editorial Board

Journal of Islamic Law and Legal Studies (JILLS) recognizes the increasing use of generative artificial intelligence (AI) and AI-assisted technologies in academic writing, legal research, jurisprudential analysis, and scholarly publishing.

Although these technologies may support certain research and communication activities, their use raises significant concerns regarding academic originality, accuracy, intellectual property, confidentiality, research integrity, and scholarly accountability.

These concerns are particularly important in Islamic law and legal studies, where the accuracy of Qur'anic references, Prophetic traditions, classical jurisprudential authorities, legal doctrines, statutory provisions, and judicial decisions is essential to the validity of scholarly arguments.

This Artificial Intelligence Policy establishes the responsibilities of authors, reviewers, and editors concerning the use of generative AI and AI-assisted technologies throughout the publication process. It distinguishes AI-assisted manuscript writing from the legitimate use of AI as a research methodology.

Fundamental Principle: Human Scholarly Accountability

Artificial intelligence cannot assume responsibility for the authenticity of Islamic legal sources, the validity of legal reasoning, the accuracy of research findings, or editorial decisions. Human authors, reviewers, and editors remain fully responsible for their scholarly and editorial activities.

1. General Principles and Scope

This policy applies to the use of generative AI and AI-assisted technologies by authors, reviewers, and editors involved in the publication process of Journal of Islamic Law and Legal Studies.

Generative AI refers to computational systems capable of generating text, images, code, audio, visual materials, or other content in response to user instructions or input data.

AI-assisted technologies may include large language models, automated writing assistants, machine learning applications, image-generation systems, and other computational tools.

The journal distinguishes between two principal categories of AI use:

AI-Assisted Academic Writing

The use of AI-assisted technologies to improve the grammar, readability, linguistic accuracy, and clarity of manuscripts originally prepared by human researchers. Such activities are subject to the restrictions and disclosure requirements established in this policy.

AI as a Legal Research Methodology

The use of AI as an analytical instrument within an appropriately designed research methodology, including legal text mining, classification of judicial decisions, computational analysis of legal documents, jurisprudential corpus analysis, and other relevant research applications.

Restrictions on AI-assisted writing do not, by themselves, prohibit the legitimate use of AI as part of a research methodology. However, methodological AI use must be transparent, academically justified, and consistent with applicable research ethics, reproducibility, confidentiality, and data protection requirements.

AI-generated interpretations must not be presented as authoritative Islamic legal rulings, authenticated religious sources, or binding legal decisions without independent verification and appropriate scholarly justification.

2. AI Policy for Authors

Authors submitting manuscripts to JILLS must comply with the journal's requirements concerning the responsible and transparent use of generative AI and AI-assisted technologies.

2.1. Use of AI in Academic Writing

Generative AI and AI-assisted technologies may be used during manuscript preparation only to improve readability, grammar, language quality, and clarity of the authors' original writing.

AI-assisted writing must remain under appropriate human oversight. Authors must carefully review, verify, and edit all AI-assisted output before including it in their manuscripts.

AI tools must not replace the authors' original legal analysis, jurisprudential interpretation, doctrinal reasoning, critical evaluation, or scholarly conclusions.

Authors must recognize that AI systems may generate plausible but inaccurate legal statements, nonexistent scholarly references, fabricated judicial decisions, or misleading interpretations of Islamic legal authorities.

2.2. Mandatory AI Disclosure

Authors are required to disclose any use of generative AI or AI-assisted technologies in the preparation or editing of their manuscripts.

The disclosure must be included in the Author Ethics Statement submitted to the editorial office. The statement serves as an internal editorial record and is not ordinarily published as part of the article.

Authors must identify the AI tool used and explain the nature and extent of its contribution. The declaration must accurately reflect the activities performed.

Example of an Author AI Disclosure

Declaration of Generative AI and AI-Assisted Technologies:

During the preparation of this manuscript, the authors used [Name of AI Tool] for language editing, grammatical correction, and readability improvement. The authors independently reviewed and verified the resulting text, including all Islamic legal references, legal citations, scholarly arguments, and research conclusions, and accept full responsibility for the accuracy, originality, and integrity of the manuscript.

Authors who have not used generative AI should not submit a declaration falsely claiming such use. Any declaration must correspond to the actual manuscript preparation process.

2.3. AI Cannot Be Listed as an Author

Generative AI systems and AI-assisted technologies cannot be listed as authors or co-authors of manuscripts submitted to JILLS.

Authorship requires intellectual responsibility, accountability, approval of the final manuscript, and the ability to respond to questions concerning research integrity and scholarly conclusions.

These responsibilities can only be fulfilled by human authors. AI systems must not be presented as independent scholarly authorities or credited as responsible authors of academic findings.

2.4. Author Responsibility and Accountability

All authors remain responsible for the complete content of their submitted manuscripts, including sections edited with AI-assisted technologies.

Authors must ensure that:

  • All scholarly claims and legal arguments are supported by authentic and verifiable sources.
  • Qur'anic quotations and references are accurately reproduced and cited.
  • Hadith references are verified against appropriate source collections, with relevant authenticity considerations addressed where material to the argument.
  • Classical and contemporary Islamic jurisprudential opinions are accurately attributed to their respective authorities.
  • Statutory provisions, regulations, fatwas, and judicial decisions are authentic and appropriately cited.
  • Research findings, legal interpretations, and conclusions are not fabricated, distorted, or misleading.
  • AI-assisted content does not infringe third-party copyright or intellectual property rights.
  • The manuscript complies with the journal's Publication Ethics , Author Guidelines , and applicable research requirements.
Important Requirement for Islamic Legal Scholarship

AI-generated Qur'anic references, hadith citations, legal maxims, jurisprudential opinions, fatwas, statutory provisions, and judicial decisions must not be accepted without independent verification. The appearance of an authoritative citation does not establish its authenticity or legal validity.

2.5. AI as Part of the Legal Research Process

JILLS recognizes that AI technologies may constitute legitimate research instruments in Islamic law and legal studies when their use is methodologically justified.

Examples may include computational analysis of Islamic legal literature, classification of court judgments, legal document processing, quantitative examination of jurisprudential trends, and AI-assisted analysis of large legal text collections.

When AI forms part of the research methodology, authors must describe its implementation transparently in the appropriate methods section.

Relevant methodological information may include the AI model or application, software version, data sources, analytical procedures, validation methods, evaluation criteria, research limitations, and relevant ethical safeguards.

Authors must distinguish between automated computational outputs and independently established legal or jurisprudential findings. AI-generated classifications, summaries, or interpretations must be critically validated before being used to support scholarly conclusions.

The use of AI as a research instrument must not be misrepresented as original algorithmic development when the underlying technology was developed by another party.

3. AI-Generated Figures, Images, and Artwork

JILLS establishes specific restrictions on the use of generative AI and AI-assisted technologies to create or modify figures, images, illustrations, and other visual materials submitted for publication.

3.1. Prohibition on AI-Generated and AI-Altered Images

The use of generative AI to create or materially alter images and visual materials submitted as research evidence is not permitted, except where such use constitutes an essential and properly documented component of the research methodology.

Prohibited practices include:

  • Generating fictional historical documents or legal manuscripts and presenting them as authentic.
  • Artificially altering archival materials, court documents, or documentary evidence.
  • Adding, removing, or replacing visual elements that change the meaning of research evidence.
  • Presenting AI-generated images as genuine field observations or documentary records.
  • Generating misleading figures or illustrations that distort research findings.
  • Using AI-generated graphical abstracts or artwork without an applicable documented exception.

Routine image adjustments that do not materially alter the information represented may be acceptable. Such adjustments must not conceal or distort relevant research evidence.

3.2. Exception for AI-Based Research Methods

An exception may apply when AI-generated or AI-modified visual materials are integral to a legitimate research design.

Examples may include computational reconstruction of historical legal documents, automated document recognition, legal text visualization, or other clearly identified AI-based analytical procedures.

Such activities must be described in sufficient methodological detail to permit scholarly assessment.

Where applicable, authors should identify:

  • The AI model, application, or software used.
  • The software version and developer.
  • The purpose of AI-assisted generation or modification.
  • The original source materials or research data.
  • The relevant computational procedures.
  • The validation methods and research limitations.
  • Relevant intellectual property and confidentiality safeguards.

The editorial office may request original source materials or supporting documentation when necessary to evaluate the integrity of submitted figures.

3.3. Graphical Abstracts and Artwork

AI-generated graphical abstracts and artwork submitted as part of a manuscript are not permitted, except where a documented research-method exception applies.

Any proposed use of AI-generated cover artwork requires prior authorization from the journal editor and publisher, together with appropriate consideration of intellectual property rights.

Research Evidence Integrity

AI-generated reconstructions, illustrations, and computational outputs must be clearly distinguished from authentic historical records, original legal documents, and empirical research observations.

4. AI Policy for Reviewers

Peer reviewers must treat all submitted manuscripts, supplementary materials, research data, and editorial communications as strictly confidential.

JILLS prohibits unauthorized use of generative AI for substantive manuscript evaluation, peer-review analysis, or the preparation of independent reviewer judgments.

4.1. Manuscript Confidentiality

Reviewers must not upload, copy, or process confidential manuscripts, in whole or in part, through external generative AI systems.

This restriction protects unpublished legal arguments, original jurisprudential interpretations, confidential research data, and other materials entrusted to reviewers.

4.2. Prohibited AI Activities in Peer Review

Reviewers must not use AI systems to:

  • Evaluate confidential manuscript content.
  • Summarize unpublished manuscripts for substantive assessment.
  • Generate substantive reviewer comments or recommendations.
  • Replace independent jurisprudential or legal analysis.
  • Assess legal arguments solely through AI-generated judgments.
  • Generate acceptance or rejection recommendations.
  • Process confidential legal or empirical research materials without authorization.
  • Disclose unpublished scholarly findings to external AI services.

4.3. Limited Technical Use of AI

AI-assisted tools may be used in a limited capacity for grammar correction or language refinement of reviewer-authored text, provided that no confidential manuscript information is disclosed or processed.

Such assistance must not generate substantive scholarly evaluations or replace the reviewer's independent judgment.

Any permitted AI-assisted language use must be disclosed to the Editorial Board when the review report is submitted.

4.4. Confidentiality of Peer Review Reports

Review reports and reviewer communications are confidential. Reviewers must not upload complete review reports into external AI systems for substantive rewriting, evaluation, or content generation.

Limited language polishing may be considered only when it does not compromise confidentiality and remains consistent with this policy.

4.5. Reviewer AI Disclosure

Reviewers who use permitted minor AI-assisted technical support must disclose the tool and nature of its use to the Editorial Board.

Such disclosures are maintained as internal editorial records and are not ordinarily made public.

Reviewer Confidentiality and Independence

The double-blind peer-review process must be conducted through independent scholarly assessment by qualified human reviewers. Generative AI must not replace expertise in Islamic jurisprudence, legal methodology, or critical legal reasoning.

4.6. Reviewer Violations

Violations involving unauthorized AI-based manuscript assessment, AI-generated substantive review reports, or disclosure of confidential materials may result in appropriate editorial action.

Depending on the seriousness of the violation, possible actions may include termination of the review assignment, removal from the reviewer database, referral to the publisher, or notification to an appropriate institution.

Any response must be based on a fair assessment of the relevant evidence.

5. AI Policy for Editors

Editors are responsible for maintaining the confidentiality, independence, fairness, and integrity of the journal's editorial procedures.

Generative AI must not replace independent editorial assessment or determine publication decisions concerning submitted manuscripts.

5.1. Confidentiality of Submitted Manuscripts

Editors must treat submitted manuscripts as confidential scholarly documents.

Submitted manuscripts, manuscript excerpts, confidential legal research materials, and supplementary data must not be uploaded into external generative AI services.

Unauthorized disclosure may compromise authors' intellectual property rights, confidential research information, and applicable data protection requirements.

5.2. Confidentiality of Editorial Communications

Confidentiality extends to editorial correspondence, reviewer reports, author communications, decision letters, and internal editorial recommendations.

Editors must not upload confidential editorial communications to external generative AI tools, including for language polishing or rewriting.

Editorial communications must protect manuscript information and the identities of reviewers and other relevant parties.

5.3. AI in Editorial Evaluation and Decision-Making

The evaluation of Islamic legal scholarship requires qualified human judgment, jurisprudential expertise, critical legal reasoning, and methodological assessment.

Generative AI must not replace editors in evaluating manuscript originality, legal argumentation, methodological validity, scholarly significance, or compliance with publication ethics.

Editors must not delegate acceptance, rejection, revision, or other substantive publication decisions to AI systems.

The Editor-in-Chief or an authorized human editor remains responsible for final editorial decisions.

5.4. Editorial Assessment of Author AI Disclosures

Editors should examine AI-use declarations submitted through the Author Ethics Statement and may request clarification when a declaration is incomplete, inconsistent, or potentially incompatible with this policy.

Where AI is used as part of the research methodology, editors may assess whether the manuscript provides adequate methodological explanation and validation.

5.5. Reporting Suspected AI Policy Violations

Editors identifying possible AI-related misconduct should refer relevant concerns to the Editor-in-Chief and, where appropriate, the publisher.

Potential concerns include undisclosed AI-assisted writing, fabricated legal references, AI-generated fictional judicial decisions, misleading jurisprudential interpretations, unauthorized image generation, and confidentiality violations.

Such concerns must be evaluated fairly and according to the available evidence.

Human Editorial Oversight

Editorial responsibility must remain with qualified human editors. AI-generated assessments cannot substitute for editorial independence, legal expertise, scholarly judgment, or accountability for final publication decisions.

6. Policy Compliance and Ethical Violations

All authors, reviewers, and editors are expected to comply with this AI Policy and the journal's applicable publication ethics requirements.

Noncompliance may compromise academic originality, legal source authenticity, research reliability, confidentiality, intellectual property rights, and the integrity of the scholarly record.

6.1. Potential Policy Violations

Potential violations include:

  • Failure to disclose AI-assisted manuscript preparation when required.
  • Listing an AI system as an author or co-author.
  • Submitting prohibited AI-generated figures or artwork.
  • Presenting fabricated Qur'anic references, hadith citations, fatwas, or legal authorities as authentic sources.
  • Submitting fictional judicial decisions, statutory provisions, or scholarly references generated by AI.
  • Using AI to fabricate or misrepresent empirical research evidence.
  • Uploading confidential manuscripts to external AI services without authorization.
  • Using AI to generate substantive peer-review reports.
  • Delegating editorial decisions to AI systems.
  • Misrepresenting the nature or extent of AI assistance.

6.2. Editorial Assessment of Violations

Suspected violations must be assessed fairly, confidentially, and on the basis of relevant evidence.

The Editorial Board may request clarification, original source materials, AI-use declarations, research documentation, or other appropriate supporting information.

Affected parties should be provided a reasonable opportunity to explain the circumstances before a final determination is made.

AI-detection software results must not, by themselves, be treated as conclusive evidence of misconduct.

6.3. Possible Editorial Actions

Depending on the seriousness of the violation and the available evidence, possible editorial actions may include:

  • Requesting clarification or disclosure.
  • Requiring correction of noncompliant material.
  • Requesting independent verification of legal references.
  • Rejecting manuscripts affected by serious ethical violations.
  • Taking appropriate action concerning reviewer misconduct.
  • Referring serious concerns to the publisher or relevant institution.
  • Considering correction, expression of concern, or retraction after publication.

Editorial measures must be proportionate and consistent with applicable procedures and publication ethics standards.

6.4. Relationship with Other Publication Policies

This AI Policy should be interpreted together with the journal's Publication Ethics , Author Guidelines , Peer Review Process , Plagiarism Policy , and Retraction and Correction Policy .

Violations involving plagiarism, fabricated research evidence, misrepresentation of legal sources, or confidentiality may require additional assessment under the corresponding journal policy.

7. Policy Governance and References

7.1. Editorial Governance

This Artificial Intelligence Policy is maintained under the editorial governance of Journal of Islamic Law and Legal Studies (JILLS), in coordination with Yayasan Mabadi Iqtishad Al Islami.

The Editor-in-Chief and Editorial Board are responsible for interpreting and implementing this policy within their respective editorial roles.

7.2. Periodic Policy Review

Given the rapid development of generative AI technologies, this policy should be reviewed periodically.

Future revisions should consider developments in AI capabilities, legal research methods, research integrity, intellectual property, data protection, and recognized scholarly publishing guidance.

7.3. Relevant Guidance and Resources

The following resources provide additional context concerning AI-assisted scholarly writing, research integrity, and responsible academic publishing.

1. Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE)

Guidance and resources concerning publication ethics, research integrity, and responsible scholarly communication.

https://publicationethics.org/
2. International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE)

Recommendations addressing scholarly authorship, accountability, and AI-assisted technologies in academic publishing.

https://www.icmje.org/recommendations/
3. Journal of Islamic Law and Legal Studies (JILLS)

The journal's Publication Ethics and other editorial policies provide the institutional framework for implementing this AI Policy.

7.4. Editorial Contact

Journal: Journal of Islamic Law and Legal Studies (JILLS)

Publisher: Yayasan Mabadi Iqtishad Al Islami

Email: shariahlex@gmail.com

Editorial Contact: JILLS Contact Page

Related Journal Policies

This AI Policy should be read together with the journal's official editorial, research integrity, manuscript preparation, and publication policies.

Commitment to Responsible AI Use

Journal of Islamic Law and Legal Studies (JILLS) is committed to the responsible, transparent, ethical, and accountable use of artificial intelligence in academic research and scholarly publishing. By establishing clear requirements for authors, reviewers, and editors, safeguarding confidential research information, protecting the authenticity of Islamic legal sources, and preserving independent human judgment, the journal seeks to support methodological innovation while maintaining the credibility, integrity, and scholarly quality of Islamic law and legal studies.