Retraction and Correction Policy

Policy Overview

Journal

Journal of Islamic Law and Legal Studies (JILLS)

Publisher

Yayasan Mabadi Iqtishad Al Islami

Editorial Authority

Editor-in-Chief

Policy Framework

COPE Guidelines and Publication Ethics

Retraction

For unreliable findings or serious integrity concerns

Correction

Erratum, Corrigendum, or Addendum

Expression of Concern

For serious unresolved concerns

Article Removal

Exceptional circumstances only

Record Preservation

Transparent and permanent scholarly records

Publication Platform

Open Journal Systems (OJS)

Journal of Islamic Law and Legal Studies (JILLS) is committed to maintaining the integrity, accuracy, transparency, reliability, and accessibility of the scholarly record in Islamic law and legal studies. Despite rigorous editorial assessment and peer-review procedures, errors, methodological weaknesses, ethical concerns, or inaccuracies may be identified after an article has been published.

In Islamic legal scholarship, the integrity of published research depends not only on methodological soundness but also on the accurate representation of primary and secondary legal sources, including the Qur'an, Prophetic traditions (hadith), classical jurisprudential literature, contemporary fatwas, statutory provisions, and judicial decisions. Material errors in these sources may substantially affect legal reasoning, jurisprudential interpretation, and the reliability of scholarly conclusions.

To safeguard the credibility of academic publications, JILLS establishes mechanisms for correcting, clarifying, retracting, or, in exceptional circumstances, removing published scholarly content. All post-publication actions must be undertaken fairly, transparently, proportionately, and with due regard for the rights and responsibilities of authors, readers, reviewers, institutions, and other stakeholders.

This policy is informed by the principles and recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and relevant international practices for maintaining the integrity of the scholarly record.

Fundamental Policy Principle

The primary purpose of retraction and correction is to preserve the accuracy and integrity of scholarly literature, not to punish authors. Editorial action must be proportionate to the nature, severity, and consequences of the identified problem. Academic disagreement or legitimate differences in Islamic legal interpretation do not, by themselves, constitute grounds for retraction.

1. Article Retraction

Article retraction is a formal post-publication mechanism used to inform the academic community that a previously published article contains serious errors, unreliable findings, or substantial violations of research and publication ethics that undermine its scholarly validity or integrity.

Retraction may be appropriate when the principal findings, legal arguments, jurisprudential interpretations, or conclusions of an article can no longer be considered reliable, regardless of whether the underlying problem resulted from intentional misconduct or honest error.

1.1. Grounds for Article Retraction

JILLS may consider retracting a published article under the following circumstances:

  1. Unreliable Research Findings: Clear evidence demonstrates that the principal findings or conclusions are substantially unreliable because of fabricated or falsified data, serious methodological errors, invalid legal reasoning, incorrect analyses, or other fundamental research inaccuracies.
  2. Plagiarism and Copyright Violations: The article contains substantial plagiarism, unauthorized reproduction of copyrighted materials, serious misappropriation of intellectual property, or other violations that compromise the integrity of publication.
  3. Duplicate or Redundant Publication: Substantially the same research has been published elsewhere without appropriate disclosure, acknowledgment, cross-referencing, permission, or legitimate scholarly justification.
  4. Research Ethics Violations: The research involves serious ethical concerns, including unauthorized collection or disclosure of personal data, breaches of confidentiality, or noncompliance with applicable research ethics requirements.
  5. Authorship and Publication Misconduct: Substantiated serious authorship misconduct, fraudulent peer review, manipulation of editorial procedures, or other systematic publication misconduct compromises the article's scholarly integrity.
  6. Fabrication or Misrepresentation of Islamic Legal Sources: The article relies materially on fabricated Qur'anic quotations, nonexistent hadith references, falsely attributed jurisprudential opinions, invented fatwas, or other misrepresented Islamic legal authorities that invalidate its principal arguments.
  7. Misrepresentation of Legal Documents and Judicial Decisions: The article contains fabricated court judgments, nonexistent statutory provisions, materially altered legal documents, or misleading representations of authoritative legal sources that undermine its conclusions.
  8. Serious AI-Related Research Misconduct: The article contains fabricated references, legal authorities, research data, or substantive findings generated through artificial intelligence that materially compromise its scholarly reliability.

Retraction should not ordinarily be pursued when an identified error can be adequately resolved through a correction without undermining the reliability of the article's principal findings or conclusions.

Scholarly Disagreement and Jurisprudential Diversity

Legitimate differences among Islamic schools of jurisprudence (madhahib), competing interpretations of legal texts, and reasoned disagreements concerning legal doctrine are not grounds for retraction unless accompanied by demonstrable research unreliability, misrepresentation, or serious ethical violations.

1.2. Retraction Procedure

The journal applies the following procedure when investigating potential grounds for article retraction:

  1. Reporting: Authors, reviewers, readers, researchers, institutions, or other stakeholders may report concerns about a published article to the editorial office.
  2. Preliminary Assessment: The Editor-in-Chief or an appointed editor assesses whether the reported concerns and supporting information justify further examination.
  3. Investigation: The Editorial Team examines relevant evidence, including original research data, legal sources, jurisprudential references, court decisions, methodological documentation, supplementary materials, and editorial correspondence where appropriate.
  4. Author Response: The corresponding author and, where appropriate, co-authors are informed of the concerns and provided a reasonable opportunity to submit explanations and supporting evidence.
  5. Independent Consultation: The editor may consult independent scholars of Islamic jurisprudence, legal methodology specialists, Editorial Board members, the publisher, or relevant research institutions.
  6. Editorial Decision: The Editor-in-Chief, or an independent editor where a conflict of interest exists, determines the appropriate action based on the available evidence. Unanimous author agreement is not required when the evidence justifies retraction.
  7. Notification: The editorial decision is communicated to the authors and, where appropriate, relevant institutions or affected parties.
  8. Publication of Retraction Notice: When retraction is warranted, the journal publishes a formal retraction notice permanently linked to the original article.

The editorial office will seek to complete the assessment without unnecessary delay. The duration may vary according to the complexity of the concerns, availability of evidence, and need for independent or institutional consultation.

1.3. Publication and Visibility of Retraction Notices

A formal retraction notice should:

  • Identify the article title, authors, publication details, and DOI, where available.
  • Clearly explain the reasons for retraction and identify the party issuing the notice.
  • Distinguish honest errors from established misconduct whenever supported by the evidence.
  • Be freely and publicly accessible.
  • Be published as a separate editorial notice, with its own DOI where applicable.
  • Be permanently linked to the original article.
  • Be reflected in relevant indexing and bibliographic metadata where technically supported.
  • Provide sufficient information to prevent continued reliance on unreliable research findings or legal arguments.
Retraction and Scholarly Record Preservation

The original article will ordinarily remain available in the journal's electronic archive but will be prominently identified as "RETRACTED" on the article landing page and published document.

This practice preserves transparency, traceability, and the historical integrity of the scholarly record.

Retention of copyright does not provide authors with an automatic right to remove or retract a published article solely upon request. Such requests remain subject to the journal's editorial procedures and publication ethics requirements.

2. Article Correction

JILLS recognizes that errors may be identified after publication without necessarily invalidating the scholarly contribution of an article.

A correction may be issued when the principal findings, legal analysis, and scholarly conclusions remain substantially reliable but specific elements require amendment or clarification to ensure accuracy and transparency.

2.1. Grounds for Article Correction

Corrections may be considered under the following circumstances:

  1. Minor Research or Analytical Errors: Errors in calculations, statistical analyses, empirical findings, tables, figures, or analytical descriptions that do not fundamentally alter the principal conclusions.
  2. Authorship and Affiliation Errors: Incorrect or incomplete author names, institutional affiliations, funding acknowledgments, or contributor statements requiring formal clarification.
  3. Data and Methodological Inaccuracies: Errors involving research data, sampling procedures, doctrinal research methods, empirical legal research procedures, or methodological descriptions that can be corrected without invalidating the study.
  4. Islamic Legal Reference Errors: Incorrect verse numbering, inaccurate hadith references, incomplete citations to classical jurisprudential works, or minor attribution errors that can be corrected without changing the substance of the research conclusions.
  5. Statutory and Judicial Citation Errors: Incorrect legal provision numbers, court decision identifiers, dates, or bibliographic information requiring clarification.
  6. Other Significant Inaccuracies: Errors sufficiently important to require a formal amendment of the published scholarly record while leaving the article's principal findings reliable.

Minor typographical or formatting errors that do not affect interpretation, author attribution, or the integrity of the scholarly record may be addressed through routine editorial updates when appropriate.

2.2. Types of Corrections

The journal recognizes three principal categories of post-publication corrections:

2.2.1. Erratum (Publisher Correction)

An erratum corrects an error introduced during the journal's editorial, formatting, typesetting, metadata processing, or production procedures. Examples include incorrect bibliographic metadata, omitted text, formatting inaccuracies, misplaced tables, and other production-related errors affecting publication accuracy.

2.2.2. Corrigendum (Author Correction)

A corrigendum corrects an important error identified or acknowledged by the authors, such as inaccurate research data, incorrect legal citations, errors in jurisprudential attribution, methodological inaccuracies, or omissions that do not invalidate the article's overall scholarly conclusions.

2.2.3. Addendum

An addendum provides supplementary information or clarification necessary to improve readers' understanding of an existing publication.

An addendum must not be used to introduce substantial new research findings, fundamentally revise the original legal argument, or bypass independent editorial assessment and peer review.

2.3. Correction Procedure

The journal applies the following procedure when considering post-publication corrections:

  1. Submission of Correction Request: Authors, readers, or other relevant parties notify the editorial office and provide supporting information.
  2. Editorial Assessment: The editor evaluates the nature, significance, and implications of the reported error.
  3. Author Clarification: The authors are invited to explain the issue and propose an appropriate correction with supporting evidence.
  4. Expert Evaluation: The editor may consult reviewers, Editorial Board members, or independent experts when additional assessment is necessary.
  5. Editorial Decision: The Editor-in-Chief determines whether an erratum, corrigendum, addendum, or another editorial action is appropriate.
  6. Publication of Correction Notice: An approved correction notice is published and permanently linked to the affected article, clearly explaining the changes.

Significant corrections will be documented transparently, including the nature of the correction and its publication date.

The original publication record must be preserved. Corrections must not conceal substantial changes or misrepresent the original research findings, legal reasoning, or jurisprudential conclusions.

3. Expression of Concern

An Expression of Concern is an official editorial notice informing readers of serious questions concerning the reliability, integrity, or ethical compliance of a published article when sufficient evidence is not yet available to justify retraction or another definitive action.

JILLS may publish an Expression of Concern when:

  1. Credible allegations of research or publication misconduct have been raised but remain unresolved.
  2. An investigation is ongoing and a final determination is unlikely to be reached promptly.
  3. Available evidence suggests potential problems with research findings, legal sources, or jurisprudential interpretations but remains insufficient or inconclusive.
  4. Relevant institutions or responsible parties are unable or unwilling to conduct an appropriate investigation.
  5. The Editorial Team determines that readers should be informed about potentially significant concerns while further clarification is sought.

An Expression of Concern must identify the affected article and explain the nature of the concerns without making unsupported allegations or prematurely assigning responsibility.

The notice should be publicly accessible and permanently linked to the original publication.

Status of an Expression of Concern

An Expression of Concern does not automatically constitute a finding of misconduct and does not necessarily mean that the article will ultimately be retracted.

Following further investigation, the journal may issue a correction, publish a retraction, or release an editorial statement clarifying that the concerns have been resolved.

The outcome will be documented transparently and linked to the relevant scholarly record.

4. Article Removal

JILLS recognizes that removing published scholarly content from academic archives may compromise transparency, accessibility, and the permanence of the scholarly record.

Consequently, article removal will only be considered under exceptional circumstances when continued public availability presents a compelling legal, ethical, privacy, or safety concern that cannot be adequately addressed through correction or retraction.

Article removal may be considered when:

  1. The article contains defamatory material or infringes intellectual property rights in a manner requiring removal.
  2. A legally enforceable court order or applicable legal obligation requires removal of the published content.
  3. The article discloses sensitive personal information, confidential legal documents, protected research data, or other legally protected information without appropriate authorization.
  4. Publication creates a serious and demonstrable risk to individual privacy, legal rights, or public safety that cannot be adequately mitigated through other measures.
Exceptional Removal Principle

Article removal is different from retraction. A retracted article normally remains accessible with a clear notice, while removal restricts access to published content only where compelling circumstances justify that action.

If removal becomes necessary, the journal will ordinarily retain bibliographic metadata, including the article title, authors, publication date, and DOI, where legally permissible.

The original content should be replaced by an explanatory notice identifying the removal and stating its reasons to the extent permitted by law and ethical obligations.

The journal will seek to preserve the integrity of the archival record while complying with applicable legal and ethical requirements.

5. Article Replacement and Republication

In exceptional circumstances, a published article may contain fundamental errors that invalidate its original findings while the underlying research may remain academically valuable after substantial correction.

Under these conditions, JILLS may consider a retraction and republication procedure.

5.1. Conditions for Republication

Retraction and republication may be considered when:

  1. The original publication contains fundamental errors that cannot be adequately resolved through a conventional correction.
  2. The authors provide a substantially corrected manuscript supported by authentic legal sources, reliable evidence, validated research data, or revised analyses.
  3. The corrected manuscript undergoes appropriate editorial assessment and, where necessary, independent peer review.
  4. The Editor-in-Chief determines that republication serves scholarly accuracy, transparency, and research integrity.

5.2. Republication Procedure

When retraction and republication are approved:

  1. The original article will be formally retracted and remain identifiable in the scholarly record, except when removal is legally necessary.
  2. The corrected article will be treated as a distinct publication with its own bibliographic record and DOI, where applicable.
  3. A transparent explanation of the relationship between the original article and the corrected publication will be provided.
  4. The retraction notice and republished article will be linked to each other to preserve the publication history.
  5. The revised publication will clearly acknowledge the retraction and republication of the original article.
Transparent Republication

A corrected article must not silently replace the original publication or conceal the reasons for its retraction. Republication is not automatic and remains subject to editorial evaluation, research integrity requirements, and appropriate peer review.

5.3. Version Control and DOI Metadata

The journal should maintain clear relationships between original articles, retraction notices, corrections, and republished versions through appropriate links and bibliographic metadata.

Where applicable, the editorial office should follow relevant Crossref guidance on version control, corrections, and retractions .

6. Reporting Concerns and Editorial Responsibility

JILLS encourages authors, reviewers, researchers, readers, academic institutions, and other stakeholders to report potential errors, research misconduct, or ethical concerns regarding published articles.

Reports should include sufficient information to support objective assessment, including the article title, DOI or URL, a clear description of the concern, and available supporting evidence.

6.1. Reporting Procedure

Concerns may be submitted directly to the journal's editorial office through its official communication channel.

The editorial office will conduct an initial assessment and determine whether clarification, further investigation, independent expert consultation, or another editorial response is necessary.

All reports should be evaluated objectively with appropriate confidentiality and respect for the rights and reputations of the parties involved.

Editorial Contact

Journal: Journal of Islamic Law and Legal Studies (JILLS)

Publisher: Yayasan Mabadi Iqtishad Al Islami

Contact Channel: Official JILLS editorial office through the journal's OJS Contact page .

6.2. Editorial Responsibility

The Editor-in-Chief retains responsibility for final editorial decisions regarding corrections, expressions of concern, retractions, and other post-publication actions, except when a conflict of interest requires the matter to be assigned to an independent editor.

Editorial decisions must be guided by reliable evidence, publication ethics, procedural fairness, and editorial independence.

Decisions must not be subject to inappropriate influence from authors, institutions, sponsors, or commercial interests.

6.3. Confidentiality and Procedural Fairness

The journal will seek to protect confidential information and avoid making unsupported allegations while concerns are being assessed.

Where appropriate, affected authors and other relevant parties will have a reasonable opportunity to provide explanations and supporting evidence.

Editorial investigations must distinguish between substantiated misconduct, honest research errors, and legitimate scholarly disagreement, particularly in matters involving Islamic jurisprudential interpretation and legal doctrinal debate.

6.4. Transparency and Timely Action

JILLS is committed to taking appropriate corrective action promptly once sufficient evidence becomes available.

Significant post-publication amendments should be communicated transparently to the academic community and accurately reflected in the relevant article records.

Further information regarding editorial accountability, research integrity, and publication misconduct should be read in conjunction with the journal's Publication Ethics policy .

7. Policy References

This policy is informed by internationally recognized guidance and best practices concerning research integrity, retractions, corrections, expressions of concern, and scholarly metadata management.

1. Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

Retraction Guidelines.

https://doi.org/10.24318/cope.2019.1.4
2. Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

Expressions of Concern.

https://publicationethics.org/guidance/guideline/expressions-concern
3. Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

COPE Flowcharts and Guidance.

https://publicationethics.org/guidance/flowcharts
4. Crossref.

Version Control, Corrections, and Retractions.

https://www.crossref.org/documentation/principles-practices/best-practices/versioning/

Related Journal Policies

This Retraction and Correction Policy should be read together with the journal's other research integrity, editorial, and publication policies.

Commitment to the Scholarly Record

Journal of Islamic Law and Legal Studies (JILLS) is committed to safeguarding the integrity, accuracy, transparency, and accessibility of scholarly publications. Through responsible editorial investigation, transparent correction and retraction procedures, rigorous verification of Islamic legal sources, and preservation of publication records, the journal seeks to maintain scholarly credibility and promote responsible research practices in Islamic law and legal studies.