Withdrawal of Manuscript
Policy Overview
Journal of Islamic Law and Legal Studies (JILLS)
Yayasan Mabadi Iqtishad Al Islami
Submitted but unpublished manuscripts
Corresponding Author
Written request and co-author consent
Written declaration or withdrawal form, where required
Editor-in-Chief or authorized editor
Effective only after written confirmation
Governed by post-publication policies
Free of charge
Journal of Islamic Law and Legal Studies (JILLS) recognizes that authors may occasionally have legitimate reasons to request the withdrawal of a manuscript after submission. However, manuscript withdrawal must be conducted responsibly, transparently, and in accordance with established principles of publication ethics and scholarly integrity.
The evaluation of manuscripts in Islamic law and legal studies requires substantial academic and administrative resources, including the intellectual contributions of editors, peer reviewers, and journal personnel. Authors are therefore expected to submit manuscripts in good faith, ensure the reliability of their research, and carefully consider their publication decisions before initiating the editorial process.
JILLS generally discourages manuscript withdrawal without reasonable justification, particularly after peer review, revision, editorial acceptance, or production activities have commenced. Nevertheless, legitimate withdrawal requests will be assessed fairly and proportionately according to the circumstances of each case.
Withdrawal requests must be submitted through an official editorial communication channel and must not be used to circumvent publication ethics, facilitate simultaneous submissions, conceal research misconduct, or disregard the contributions of editors and reviewers.
Manuscript withdrawal concerns a submission that has not yet been formally published. Once an article has been published, requests involving corrections, expressions of concern, retractions, or exceptional removal must be addressed under the journal's Retraction and Correction Policy .
Contents
1. General Principles and Scope
This policy applies to manuscripts submitted to Journal of Islamic Law and Legal Studies (JILLS) that remain within the editorial and publication process but have not yet been formally published.
Authors are expected to ensure that a manuscript is ready for scholarly evaluation before submission and that all co-authors have approved the submission and its contents.
The journal recognizes that manuscript withdrawal may become necessary under legitimate circumstances. Requests will be assessed according to the manuscript's editorial stage, the reasons provided, the authorization of the authors, and any relevant ethical or publishing obligations.
A withdrawal request does not automatically terminate the editorial process. A manuscript remains under the journal's consideration until the editorial office communicates formal written confirmation of its withdrawal.
The journal seeks to balance authors' legitimate interests with the responsibilities associated with responsible scholarly communication, editorial fairness, and the integrity of academic publishing.
2. Grounds for Manuscript Withdrawal
Authors requesting manuscript withdrawal must provide a clear, specific, and reasonable explanation. Circumstances that may justify withdrawal include the following:
- Serious Research Errors: The authors identify material errors in research data, legal analysis, jurisprudential interpretation, empirical findings, or methodological procedures that substantially compromise the manuscript's reliability.
- Authorship Disputes: A significant authorship or contributorship disagreement emerges and cannot be appropriately resolved during editorial processing.
- Research Ethics Concerns: The authors identify important problems involving ethical approval, informed consent, confidentiality, data protection, or authorization to use research materials.
- Intellectual Property Issues: There is an unresolved copyright, permission, ownership, or other intellectual property concern affecting the lawful publication of the manuscript.
- Significant Errors in Islamic Legal Sources: The authors discover serious inaccuracies in Qur'anic references, hadith attribution, classical jurisprudential sources, fatwas, or other Islamic legal authorities that materially undermine the research arguments.
- Material Errors in Legal Documents: The manuscript contains substantial inaccuracies involving legislation, judicial decisions, regulatory instruments, or other legal documents that cannot be adequately resolved through ordinary revision.
- Submission Error: A manuscript was submitted unintentionally or to the wrong journal, and the mistake is promptly reported with a reasonable explanation.
- Other Compelling Circumstances: Exceptional reasons supported by credible information that justify discontinuation of editorial consideration.
A withdrawal request based solely on an author's preference to submit the same manuscript to another journal after receiving editorial or reviewer feedback is not ordinarily considered sufficient justification, particularly where substantial editorial work has already been completed.
Legitimate differences in Islamic jurisprudential interpretation, legal doctrine, or scholarly perspective do not, by themselves, constitute research misconduct. Withdrawal requests involving such differences should be distinguished from cases of demonstrable factual error, source fabrication, or serious methodological deficiency.
3. Withdrawal at Different Editorial Stages
3.1. Before Peer Review
When a manuscript has been submitted but has not yet entered external peer review, authors may submit a formal withdrawal request to the editorial office.
The Editorial Team will examine the request, verify the manuscript information and author authorization, and determine whether the submission may be closed.
Where the request is legitimate and no significant ethical or administrative concern is identified, withdrawal may be approved and recorded in the journal's editorial system.
3.2. During Peer Review
Withdrawal during peer review is discouraged because editors and reviewers may already have invested substantial time and scholarly effort in evaluating the manuscript.
Authors requesting withdrawal at this stage must provide a formal written explanation and appropriate co-author consent. The Editor-in-Chief or an authorized editor will evaluate the circumstances before determining the appropriate response.
When withdrawal is approved, the editorial office should close the relevant review assignments and notify affected editors or reviewers as appropriate.
3.3. During Revision
Authors should not use withdrawal as a means of avoiding legitimate peer-review criticism or transferring an actively reviewed manuscript to another journal without concluding the original submission process.
A request for withdrawal during revision must identify the manuscript, provide supporting reasons, and be communicated through the official editorial channel.
The Editorial Team may seek clarification or discuss whether the identified concerns can be resolved through revision before completing the withdrawal assessment.
3.4. After Acceptance but Before Publication
Once a manuscript has been accepted for publication, withdrawal becomes particularly sensitive because additional editorial, production, and administrative commitments may have been undertaken.
Authors must provide compelling reasons for withdrawal after acceptance. The editorial office will examine the stage of production, applicable publishing arrangements, co-author consent, and any relevant research integrity concerns.
Approval remains subject to editorial assessment and any applicable publishing agreements entered into by the authors and publisher.
Where an Article Processing Charge (APC) has become applicable, any financial matter must be addressed in accordance with the journal's publicly disclosed Publication Fees Policy and applicable agreements.
3.5. After Publication
A formally published article cannot be treated as an ordinary unpublished manuscript withdrawal.
Any request involving an already published article must be considered under the journal's Retraction and Correction Policy , which governs corrections, expressions of concern, retractions, and exceptional article removal.
4. Withdrawal Request and Documentation
The corresponding author should submit a formal written withdrawal request to the JILLS editorial office.
The request should contain the following information:
- Full manuscript title.
- Manuscript ID or OJS submission identification number.
- Full names of all authors.
- Name and email address of the corresponding author.
- Current editorial status of the manuscript.
- A clear explanation of the reason for withdrawal.
- Supporting documentation, where appropriate.
- Confirmation that all co-authors have been informed and agree to the request.
- A completed withdrawal form or written declaration, where required by the editorial office.
4.1. Withdrawal Declaration or Form
Authors may be required to provide a formal withdrawal declaration or an Article Withdrawal Form where such documentation is prescribed by the editorial office.
The declaration should identify the manuscript, state the reasons for withdrawal, and confirm that the request has been authorized by the relevant authors.
The editorial office may request written confirmation from individual co-authors when necessary to verify authorization, resolve disputed consent, or clarify authorship-related concerns.
4.2. Submission of the Request
Authors should submit their withdrawal request through the journal's official editorial communication channel, including the relevant communication facility within Open Journal Systems (OJS).
Editorial Office — Journal of Islamic Law and Legal Studies (JILLS)
Communication Channel: Official JILLS Contact Page or OJS editorial correspondence.
Authors must not assume that a manuscript has been withdrawn merely because a request has been submitted.
5. Editorial Assessment and Decision
JILLS evaluates withdrawal requests through a documented editorial process, taking into consideration the reasons provided, the manuscript's editorial status, co-author authorization, and any relevant ethical or publishing concerns.
5.1. Withdrawal Assessment Procedure
- Receipt: The editorial office receives and records the withdrawal request.
- Verification: The manuscript ID, title, authorship information, and current submission status are checked.
- Author Authorization: The editorial office verifies that the request is authorized by the corresponding author and that co-authors have provided appropriate consent.
- Editorial Review: The reasons for withdrawal and any relevant ethical, technical, legal, or production-related concerns are evaluated.
- Decision: The Editor-in-Chief or authorized editor determines the appropriate course of action.
- Notification: The corresponding author receives formal written communication regarding the editorial decision.
- Record Management: Approved withdrawal requests are recorded and processed in the journal's editorial system.
5.2. Requests Involving Ethical Concerns
When a withdrawal request involves suspected duplicate submission, fabricated research data, plagiarism, disputed authorship, misrepresented legal sources, unauthorized research activities, or other significant ethical concerns, the Editorial Team may seek additional clarification.
A request to withdraw a manuscript does not automatically terminate an ongoing investigation concerning research or publication misconduct.
The journal may address substantiated misconduct under its Publication Ethics Policy and other relevant editorial procedures.
5.3. Administrative and Financial Matters
JILLS does not charge a manuscript submission fee. The Article Processing Charge (APC) is IDR 350,000 per accepted article, subject to the journal's published Publication Fees Policy and applicable waiver arrangements.
The existence of an APC does not automatically establish a manuscript withdrawal penalty. Any financial obligation associated with withdrawal must have a clear basis in a publicly disclosed journal policy or an applicable agreement.
Authors should consult the journal's Publication Fees Policy for information regarding applicable publication charges and requests for fee waivers.
6. Ethical Restrictions and Author Responsibilities
Manuscript withdrawal must be conducted in accordance with the principles of responsible scholarly communication, academic honesty, and publication ethics.
The following practices are inconsistent with responsible manuscript withdrawal:
- Submitting the same or substantially similar manuscript to another journal while it remains under active consideration by JILLS.
- Requesting withdrawal solely because the manuscript has been accepted by another journal following simultaneous submission.
- Using withdrawal to conceal plagiarism, fabricated research findings, false legal references, authorship disputes, or other significant ethical concerns.
- Submitting a withdrawal request without appropriate authorization from co-authors.
- Misrepresenting the manuscript's editorial status or providing false reasons for withdrawal.
- Treating an unconfirmed withdrawal request as formal permission to submit the manuscript elsewhere.
Authors must not submit substantially the same manuscript to another journal while it remains under consideration by JILLS. Where withdrawal has been requested, authors must first obtain official written confirmation that the submission has been closed.
An ordinary, legitimate withdrawal request should not automatically be characterized as research misconduct. Allegations of misconduct must be assessed separately and supported by relevant evidence.
Authors and editors share responsibility for maintaining fairness, confidentiality, professional communication, and appropriate records throughout the withdrawal process.
7. Confirmation, Contact, and Policy Governance
7.1. Official Withdrawal Confirmation
A manuscript is considered formally withdrawn only after the journal's editorial office has issued written confirmation.
The confirmation should identify the affected manuscript and communicate that the submission has been closed or otherwise formally discontinued.
Until that confirmation is issued, authors must continue to comply with their responsibilities regarding exclusive submission and publication ethics.
7.2. Editorial Contact
Journal: Journal of Islamic Law and Legal Studies (JILLS)
Publisher: Yayasan Mabadi Iqtishad Al Islami
Contact: Official JILLS editorial office through the journal's OJS communication facilities or official Contact page .
7.3. Complaints and Appeals
Authors who believe that a significant procedural or factual error affected a withdrawal decision may submit a reasoned appeal through the official editorial communication channel.
The appeal should provide relevant supporting evidence and will be considered in accordance with the journal's editorial governance and Publication Ethics requirements.
Where a conflict of interest affects the original decision, the journal should arrange an independent editorial assessment where practicable.
7.4. Policy Governance and Review
This policy is maintained under the editorial governance of Journal of Islamic Law and Legal Studies (JILLS) in coordination with its publisher, Yayasan Mabadi Iqtishad Al Islami.
The policy should be periodically reviewed to ensure consistency with the journal's editorial practices, research integrity standards, applicable publishing agreements, and relevant guidance from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) .
Related Journal Policies
This Withdrawal of Manuscript Policy should be read together with the journal's other editorial, submission, research integrity, and post-publication policies.
Commitment to Responsible Manuscript Withdrawal
Journal of Islamic Law and Legal Studies (JILLS) is committed to maintaining fairness, transparency, accountability, and ethical integrity throughout manuscript submission and editorial evaluation. Withdrawal requests are handled through formal procedures that respect legitimate author interests, acknowledge the contributions of editors and reviewers, and protect the integrity of scholarly publishing in Islamic law and legal studies.